Hi, I’m Eddy.

Trading strategies.
Put to the test.

I take popular YouTube setups, write the rules down, and test them against prop firm conditions. This site is the library of those results — including the ones that failed.

Thumbnail of my video testing Justin Chuk's ORB vs the Traditional ORB

The newest tests

Justin Chuk's ORB vs the Traditional ORB

Positive test

On one MNQ contract over 7 years it made about $12,500 with no losing year, and it beat the traditional ORB. But at his own challenge size, only about 27% of prop firm challenges passed.

Trades
822
Win rate
55.6%
Profit factor
1.3
Net
+$12,501
02
Start here

Six tests worth watching first

What held up, what failed, and what changed in a longer backtest.

What the labels mean

  • Positive testThe test made money.
  • Failed testThe test lost money.
  • Mixed resultsOne try worked. Another did not.
  • InconclusiveNo clear pass or fail.
  • GuideA guide, not a score.
03
Claim vs test

What they said, and what I measured

Reported win rates next to my backtest results. Test periods and rule readings can differ; each breakdown explains the context.

Nico Trades · win rate

Read the breakdown →
Reported: 80–85%
My test: 42%

Simplified Trader · win rate

Read the breakdown →
Reported: ~71%
My test: 34%

Simplified Trader gold OTE · win rate

Read the breakdown →
Reported: 70%
My test: 33%
04
Compare

The biggest samples, side by side

A pass on 20 trades means less than a result on 1,000. Every test gets the same scorecard, so you can see which results rest on real sample size.

Strategy tests compared. Select a column heading to sort.
StrategyResultBiggest dropNet result
Nitro Trades Candle Range Theory (CRT)Coded backtest · Coded test, NQ 15m/2m, no biasFailed test1,964large samplenot reported0.8$86,390-$82,365
Casper SMC Short Session Method (SSM)Coded backtest · 5-year coded test, trade logMixed results1,910large sample69.0%1.09$24,175+$49,400
Joovier Gems London Breakout (coded 10.5-year study)Coded backtest · 10.5-year coded test (wait-for-close)Failed test1,310large sample35.9%0.92$87,790-$49,770
Justin Chuk's ORB vs the Traditional ORBCoded backtest · 7-year coded test, 1 MNQPositive test822large sample55.6%1.3$1,844+$12,501
Tim Hutter's EMA VWAP Strategy (82% pass rate claim)Coded backtest · His backtest reproduced, 3 MESMixed results396large sample56.6%1.84$2,860+$29,985
Pro Real Algos Break and BounceCoded backtest · Coded test, rules from the videoMixed results395large samplenot reported0.98not reported-$3,380
05
Method

How I test a strategy

I share the setup, the test, and the outcome so you can follow along — and so you can see where judgment still creeps in.

  1. 1

    Choose a strategy

    I start with a trading setup from YouTube and work through how it is meant to be traded.

  2. 2

    Write the rules down

    I define the entry, stop, target, and session, and explain any assumptions needed to test the setup.

  3. 3

    Run the trades

    I replay the market candle by candle, or I code the strategy and let it run over years of data.

  4. 4

    Share the results

    I report whether it passed the rules I tested, note the sample size, and say where judgment still affected the trades.

The results

For everyone. Every breakdown, every trade log, the prop firm simulator and calculator, and the rules compared.

07
Up next

You pick what gets tested

Most tests start as a comment. These are the most requested so far.

  1. ICT / Smart Money Concepts23 requests
  2. Fair Value Gap (FVG) entries21 requests
  3. Opening Range Breakout (ORB)12 requests