← All results
Mixed results

Simplified Trader 9:30am Model

It won 34% of trades and finished about even when the target was twice the risk. A what-if on the same trades says a smaller target would have passed.

Source The Simplified TraderVideo published Mar 15, 2026
Watch the video
Scorecard · As traded at 2RLarge sample · 100 trades
Trades
100
Win rate
34%
Profit factor
1.03
Reward : risk
2R
Biggest drop
~9.5% average
Net result
~$100

A dash means the video did not report that number.

Two ways to check this test

Estimate with these stats

The simulator makes up thousands of random runs from this test’s win rate and reward-to-risk, then checks each prop firm’s rules. The wins and losses are random, not my trades.

Run the simulator

Open the actual trade log

Every trade from my test, in the order it happened. The numbers on this page come from these trades.

My breakdown

The claim

The Simplified Trader's inverse FVG strategy did well when I tested it, so when he released a new one, the 9:30 AM model, I had high hopes. The thumbnail implied a 71% win rate.

The strategy in plain English

The 9:30 model uses the first 5-minute candle after the New York open as the key range, and trades the reaction to it at a 2R target. This video was about the claim versus the result, so I didn't go through every rule in it. The original video is linked from the YouTube description.

His explanation left out a few rules that change the results, so I had to choose:

  • Do you skip news days?
  • What's the latest time to look for a trade?
  • Do you only trade the first breakout direction?
  • Do you exit at the end of the day?

How I tested it

I replayed 100 trades from January 2 to July 2, 2025, against FTMO-style rules: two phases, a 15% total target and a 10% maximum drawdown. I tested it at both 0.5% and 1% risk.

What happened

As traded at 2R:

  • 34% win rate, nowhere near 71%
  • $1.03 made for every $1 lost, basically break-even
  • about $100 net profit
  • an average drawdown around 9.5%

At 1% risk, it passed phase 1 and then failed phase 2 by hitting the maximum drawdown. At 0.5% risk, it didn't pass either phase, but it didn't fail either. It just went sideways.

Tuesday was the worst day, at about a 24% win rate.

The target was the problem

Over and over, price would move cleanly to about 1R in my favour, sometimes nearly reach 2R, and then turn around and hit the stop. So I ran the same 100 trades through FX Replay's risk-reward simulator:

  • At 1R: a 59% win rate, about +$1,800 (18%), $1.44 per $1 lost, and an average drawdown of only 2.7%. That would have passed the challenge.

So the idea isn't worthless. The exit is what's killing it. But this is a what-if on the same trades, not a new test, so it needs its own test before anyone trusts it.

Why the 71% claim is a problem

When rules aren't written out, it's easy to adjust them until you get a win rate you like: take partial profits, use a smaller target, skip the losing days. A 71% win rate might be a real number for a slightly different strategy. It's not the number for the rules as shown.

Takeaway

If you trade this model, test the 1R version properly before you use it, and decide the missing rules up front. My guide on whether YouTube strategies work shows this isn't the only win-rate claim that came in at about half.

The test

How I tested
Manual replay
When
2 January 2025 to 2 July 2025
Market
Not said in the video
Trades
More than one stretch of trades. See below.
Risk per trade
Not said in the video
Fees
Not said in the video

Trade log

Simplified Trader 9:30am Model

Download PDFDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.

More from the test

Rules
FTMO-style: two phases, 15% total target, 10% max drawdown
Test window
2 January 2025 to 2 July 2025
Creator claim
71% win rate implied by thumbnail
As traded 2r
100 trades, 34% WR, PF 1.03, ~$100 net profit, ~9.5% average drawdown
Risk 1 percent
Passed step 1, failed step 2 by hitting max drawdown
Risk 0 5 percent
Passed neither phase but also did not fail
At 1r
59% WR, ~$1,800 (~18%), PF 1.44, 2.7% average drawdown
Worst day
Tuesday, ~24% win rate

A note

I had to guess a few rules: news days, the cutoff time, repeat entries, and end-of-day exits. The what-if uses the same trades. It is not a new test.

Where the numbers come from

Checked Sep 22, 2026. These numbers come from the video. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.

Original video ↗

Test your own trades

EdgeFinder

The app I built to log a backtest and run it through prop firm challenge rules. It is free to try.

Try EdgeFinder free ↗

Backtest Lab

Members get the code behind my backtests, the results before the video goes public, and a vote on what I test next.

Join Backtest Lab ↗

EdgeFinder is my app and Backtest Lab is my channel membership, so both of these pay me. They never change a test result.