Justin Chuk's ORB vs the Traditional ORB
On one MNQ contract over 7 years it made about $12,500 with no losing year, and it beat the traditional ORB. But at his own challenge size, only about 27% of prop firm challenges passed.
▶ Watch the video- Trades
- 822
- Win rate
- 55.6%
- Profit factor
- 1.3
- Reward : risk
- 1R
- Biggest drop
- $1,844
- Net result
- +$12,501
A dash means the video did not report that number.
Two ways to check this test
EdgeFinder is my app, so it pays me. It never changes a test result. No account needed to open the trades.
My breakdown
Why this ORB is different
Opening range breakout videos are everywhere on YouTube. This one comes from Justin Chuk, who studied business at UC Berkeley, worked in private equity and quantitative research, and wrote a paper on the ORB in Nasdaq futures. His version adds two simple filters to the traditional ORB, and they made a real difference.
The traditional ORB (what I compared against)
- Mark the high and low of the first 30 minutes, 9:30 to 10:00 AM New York time.
- After 10:00, wait for a 5-minute candle to close above the high. Buy at the start of the next minute.
- Stop at the low of the 30-minute range.
- Target 1:1: the same distance above your entry as the stop is below it.
- If neither is hit, close at 2:00 PM.
- Longs only, one trade a day.
Justin Chuk's two extra rules
- Skip wide mornings. If the first 30 minutes moved more than 0.85% of the price, don't trade. With NQ around 30,000, that's a range wider than about 255 points.
- Skip Fed days. No trade on the day of a scheduled Fed interest rate decision.
That's the entire difference. Everything else is identical.
How I tested it
MNQ 1-minute data from May 2019 to September 2026, one contract per trade. Costs: $2 per contract round trip, 1 tick of slippage on entries and time exits, and 2 ticks on stops. If a single 1-minute candle touched both the stop and the target, I counted the stop. A separate run by ChatGPT matched mine trade for trade.
What happened
Justin Chuk's ORB:
- 822 trades, a 55.6% win rate
- +$12,501 on one MNQ contract
- $1.30 made for every $1 lost
- biggest drop $1,844
- no losing year (2026 is a partial year)
Traditional ORB:
- 1,107 trades
- +$10,286
- biggest drop $2,875
- losing years in 2020 and 2022
Justin's version took about 300 fewer trades and still made more. On the exact mornings it skipped, the traditional ORB lost about $2,200. The filter didn't find better trades. It avoided bad days.
One honest note: in 2026 so far, the traditional ORB is ahead, at +$3,387 vs +$1,798. The filter costs you in some calm stretches.
With Justin's own sizing rule (risk up to $400 a trade, 1 to 4 MNQ), it made +$19,027, but most of the extra came from the early years.
Could it pass a prop firm challenge?
Using Lucid Trading and Tradeify 50K rules (as checked October 25, 2026):
- At his challenge size (risking up to $1,100 a trade, about five weeks per attempt): only 27.7% passed, about the same as the traditional ORB at 27.8%. A $2,000 drawdown can't absorb normal losing streaks at that size.
- Risking a third of the room left above the drawdown floor (my rule, not his): about 51% passed, vs about 31% for the traditional ORB, but it took 9 to 10 months.
The payout trap
In the funded account, taking the biggest payout every time left 86% of Lucid accounts dead within a year, because each withdrawal pulled the balance back toward the drawdown line. Keeping $2,000 of room in the account before withdrawing: 0 of 1,660 simulated accounts blew up at Lucid, and 2 of 1,660 at Tradeify.
Takeaway
This is the only coded test on the site that came out clearly positive. The edge is modest, at 55.6% on a 1:1 target, but it's real over seven years and survives costs. How you size it and how you take payouts matter as much as the strategy. The step-by-step breakdown shows every rule on real days, the code pack has the indicator and code, and the ORB results guide compares it with every other ORB I've tested.
The test
- How I tested
- Coded backtest
- When
- May 2019 to Sep 2026
- Market
- MNQ futures, 5-minute close, 30-minute opening range
- Trades
- 822 trades
- Risk per trade
- One MNQ contract
- Fees
- $2 per contract round trip, 1 tick of slippage on the entry and time exits, 2 ticks on stops
The numbers
Trade log
All 822 trades
Open trade log in EdgeFinder · Justin Chuk's ORBOpens every trade in EdgeFinder, the app I built. No account needed.All 1,107 trades
Open trade log in EdgeFinder · Traditional ORBOpens every trade in EdgeFinder, the app I built. No account needed.More from the test
- Instrument
- MNQ
- Coverage
- May 2019 to Sep 2026
- Traditional ORB
- 1,107 trades, +$10,286, $2,875 max drawdown, losing years in 2020 and 2022
- This year
- 2026 so far: traditional ORB +$3,387, Justin Chuk +$1,798
- With 400 risk
- With his $400 risk rule (1 to 4 MNQ): +$19,027, but most of the extra came from the early years
- Challenge his size
- Risking up to $1,100 a trade, about 5 weeks: Justin Chuk 27.7%, traditional 27.8% passed
- Challenge room
- Risking a third of the room left, 9 to 10 months: Justin Chuk about 51%, traditional about 31% passed
- Funded payouts
- Taking the biggest payout every time: 86% of Lucid accounts dead within a year. Keeping $2,000 of room: 0 of 1,660 blown at Lucid, 2 of 1,660 at Tradeify
A note
Backtest only, long trades only, out at 2 PM. No losing year refers to the one-contract test, and 2026 is a partial year. Prop firm rules are Lucid Trading and Tradeify 50K as checked on October 25, 2026.
Where the numbers come from
Checked Nov 1, 2026. These numbers come from the video. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.
Original video ↗Supporting source ↗Supporting source ↗