← All results
Mixed results

Nico Trades 5-Minute Opening Range Reversal (inverted FVG entry)

One practice challenge passed and the next one failed. Together they won 42% of trades. The original claim was 80–85%.

Source Nico TradesVideo published Jun 27, 2026
Watch the video
Scorecard · Both challenges combinedMedium sample · 68 trades
Trades
68
Win rate
42%
Profit factor
1.27
Reward : risk
—
Biggest drop
—
Net result
just under +5%

A dash means the video did not report that number.

Two ways to check this test

Estimate with these stats

The simulator makes up thousands of random runs from this test’s win rate and reward-to-risk, then checks each prop firm’s rules. The wins and losses are random, not my trades.

Run the simulator

Open the actual trade log

Every trade from my test, in the order it happened. The numbers on this page come from these trades.

My breakdown

The claim

Nico Trades says this simple 5-minute scalping strategy has an 80–85% win rate. That's a big claim, so I tested it through two separate prop firm challenges instead of one.

The strategy in plain English

It's an opening range reversal. Instead of trading the breakout of the first 5 minutes, you wait for price to poke out of the range, fail, and come back.

  1. On the 5-minute chart, mark the high and low of the 9:30 AM candle.
  2. On the 1-minute chart, wait for price to sweep (go beyond) either the high or the low.
  3. Wait for the fair value gap closest to the range to be inverted: a candle closes through it in the opposite direction. That's the entry.
  4. Stop at the wick of the move. If that gives a reward-to-risk under 1, use the candle body instead. Nico says either works.
  5. Target the other side of the range.

How I tested it

I replayed MNQ starting January 2, 2026, using one to four contracts and never more than 0.5% risk a trade. The rules were Lucid Trading's LucidFlex: a 5% profit target, a 4% maximum drawdown, and a 50% consistency rule.

What happened

Challenge 1: passed.

  • 37 trades, a 54% win rate
  • $2 made for every $1 lost
  • took 72 days, with only $44 in commissions
  • longest losing streak 3

Challenge 2: failed.

  • 31 trades, a 29% win rate
  • lost slightly more than it made
  • the maximum drawdown was hit on trade 31
  • longest losing streak 5

Both together: 68 trades, a 42% win rate, about $1.27 made per $1 lost, and just under +5% over roughly six months.

So is the 80–85% claim true?

Not in my test. The best stretch won 54%, and the overall number was 42%, about half the claim. To be fair to Nico, the strategy doesn't need 80%. Because the target is the far side of the range, winners are often bigger than losers, which is why the first challenge passed at 54%.

The problem is what happened next. The same rules, a few weeks later, won 29% and failed. That's the pattern I see over and over: a strategy passes one stretch, and people assume it will pass the next.

Takeaway

If you trade this, don't size it like an 80% strategy. Size it like a 42% one, and expect five or more losses in a row. And if you only test one challenge's worth of trades, test a second one before you trust the first. My guide on whether YouTube strategies work compares this claim with others I've checked, and the ORB results guide puts it next to every other opening range strategy I've tested.

The test

How I tested
Manual replay
When
Not said in the video
Market
MNQ, 1-4 contracts, max 0.5% risk per trade
Trades
More than one stretch of trades. See below.
Risk per trade
Not said in the video
Fees
Not said in the video

Trade log

Passed test

Download PDF · Passed testDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.

Failed test

Download PDF · Failed testDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.

More from the test

Instrument
MNQ, 1-4 contracts, max 0.5% risk per trade
Rules
Lucid Trading LucidFlex: 5% profit target, 4% max drawdown, 50% consistency rule
Creator claim
80-85% win rate
Challenge 1
PASSED - 37 trades, 54% WR, PF 2.0, 72 days, $44 commissions, 3 max consecutive losses
Challenge 2
FAILED - 31 trades, 29% WR, PF 0.9, max drawdown hit at trade 31, 5 max consecutive losses
Combined
68 trades, 42% WR, PF 1.27, just under +5% net over ~6 months

Where the numbers come from

Checked Sep 22, 2026. These numbers come from the video. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.

Original video ↗

Test your own trades

EdgeFinder

The app I built to log a backtest and run it through prop firm challenge rules. It is free to try.

Try EdgeFinder free ↗

Backtest Lab

Members get the code behind my backtests, the results before the video goes public, and a vote on what I test next.

Join Backtest Lab ↗

EdgeFinder is my app and Backtest Lab is my channel membership, so both of these pay me. They never change a test result.