← All results
Mixed results

Tim Hutter's EMA VWAP Strategy (82% pass rate claim)

His backtest is real: I matched it to the dollar at $29,985. But with every trade closed by My Funded Futures' 4:10 PM cutoff and open losses counted, it failed 5 challenges and passed none.

Source Tim HutterVideo published Oct 22, 2026
Watch the video
Scorecard · His backtest reproduced, 3 MESLarge sample · 396 trades
Trades
396
Win rate
56.6%
Profit factor
1.84
Reward : risk
—
Biggest drop
$2,860
Net result
+$29,985

A dash means the video did not report that number.

Two ways to check this test

Estimate with these stats

The simulator makes up thousands of random runs from this test’s win rate and reward-to-risk, then checks each prop firm’s rules. The wins and losses are random, not my trades.

Run the simulator

Open the actual trade log

Every trade from my test, in the order it happened. The numbers on this page come from these trades.

EdgeFinder is my app, so it pays me. It never changes a test result. No account needed to open the trades.

My breakdown

The claim

Tim Hutter says this EMA + VWAP strategy has an 82% prop firm pass rate. He publishes his backtest and settings, so I could check his numbers exactly, and then check them against real prop firm rules.

The rules in plain English

Times are New York. Longs are described here; shorts are the mirror image.

  • Chart: 3-minute candles on MES, with VWAP (reset at midnight, overnight included) and an 11-period EMA.
  • Volatility filter: a signal only counts when recent volatility (14-candle ATR) is no more than 1.1 times the longer-term volatility (50-candle ATR).
  • Trend entry: the EMA is above VWAP, and a candle closes above the EMA. Buy.
  • Pullback entry: after a trade has exited, the EMA crosses above VWAP, then the first candle that closes below VWAP after one that closed at or above it is a buy.
  • Exit: the first candle that closes below the EMA.
  • No stop loss and no target. Signals and exits are only read from 9:30 AM to 4:00 PM, so trades can be held overnight.
  • Daily limit: a winning first trade ends the day. After a first loss, two more tries.
  • 3 MES contracts, filled at the next candle's open.

His backtest is real

I ran his published code and settings from January 2023 to September 25, 2026, with $0.50 per contract per side and 0.005% slippage on every fill:

  • 396 trades, 224 wins and 172 losses, a 56.6% win rate
  • +$29,985 on 3 MES contracts, matching his number to the dollar
  • $1.84 made for every $1 lost
  • biggest drop $2,860

Where the 82% falls apart

The overnight problem. The trades that made most of the money were held overnight. My Funded Futures doesn't allow that: every position has to be closed by 4:10 PM.

  • Closing every trade before 4:10 PM, on three micros: 6 challenges started, 5 failed, 1 still open when the data ran out. Zero passed.
  • Holding overnight and counting open losses the way a firm would: 8 passed, 8 failed. That's 50%, not 82%.

The years he didn't show. On his exact settings, 2016 to 2022 lost about $31,000. The backtest starts right where the strategy started working.

Could a different version work?

I tested 5,184 variations. The best was NQ on a 5-minute chart, EMA 50, longs only, every trade closed before 4:10 PM: +$16,231 over 437 trades on 3 micros, with 5 challenges passed and 3 failed. But that's the best of more than five thousand tries, and it still has no stop loss, so I'm not recommending it.

The prop firm rules used are My Funded Futures (checked October 15, 2026) and Apex Trader Funding (checked October 13, 2026).

Takeaway

Tim Hutter didn't fake his backtest. The problem is that the backtest doesn't follow the rules of the prop firms it's sold for, and it starts in the best stretch. Before you trust any pass rate, check two things: does the backtest close trades when the firm requires, and what happened in the years before it starts? The code pack has every trade and all 5,184 versions, and the hidden prop firm rules page covers rules like the closing time.

The test

How I tested
Coded backtest
When
Jan 2023 to Sep 25, 2026
Market
MES futures, 3-minute chart
Trades
396 trades
Risk per trade
3 micro contracts, no stop loss
Fees
$0.50 per contract per side and 0.005% slippage on every fill

The numbers

Trades396
Wins224
Losses172
Win rate56.6%
Profit+$29,985 on 3 MES contracts
Profit vs losses1.84
Biggest drop$2,860

Trade log

All 396 trades

Open trade log in EdgeFinder · His backtest, reproducedOpens every trade in EdgeFinder, the app I built. No account needed.

All 487 trades

Open trade log in EdgeFinder · Closed before 4:10 PMOpens every trade in EdgeFinder, the app I built. No account needed.

All 437 trades

Open trade log in EdgeFinder · Best of 5,184 versionsOpens every trade in EdgeFinder, the app I built. No account needed.

More from the test

Instrument
MES
Coverage
Jan 2023 to Sep 25, 2026
Claim in his video
82% prop firm pass rate
Open losses counted
Holding overnight with open losses counted: 8 passed, 8 failed
Closed by 410
Closed before 4:10 PM on three micros: 6 started, 5 failed, 1 still open when the data ran out
Years he did not show
2016 to 2022 on his exact settings: lost about $31,000
Best of 5184
Best of 5,184 versions: NQ, 5-minute, EMA 50, longs only, +$16,231 on 3 micros, 437 trades, passed 5 and failed 3 challenges, with no stop loss

A note

The trades that made most of the money were held overnight, which My Funded Futures does not allow. The best version is not a recommendation. Prop firm rules are My Funded Futures as checked on October 15, 2026 and Apex Trader Funding as checked on October 13, 2026.

Where the numbers come from

Checked Nov 1, 2026. These numbers come from the video. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.

Original video ↗Supporting source ↗

Test your own trades

EdgeFinder

The app I built to log a backtest and run it through prop firm challenge rules. It is free to try.

Try EdgeFinder free ↗

Backtest Lab

Members get the code behind my backtests, the results before the video goes public, and a vote on what I test next.

Join Backtest Lab ↗

EdgeFinder is my app and Backtest Lab is my channel membership, so both of these pay me. They never change a test result.