← All results
Positive test

Eddy's New York Breakout (Volume Profile + FVG)

This is my New York breakout. It passed an FTMO-style test in 36 trades. In those 36 trades it made about $2.52 for every $1 it lost, and the biggest drop was 3%. Across all 52 trades I replayed in 2026 it made about $2.40 for every $1 lost.

Source Eddy PipsVideo published Apr 26, 2026
Watch the video
Scorecard · Full 2026 replayMedium sample · 52 trades
Trades
52
Win rate
71%
Profit factor
2.4
Reward : risk
1R
Biggest drop
3% (~$300)
Net result
just under +21%

A dash means the video did not report that number.

Two ways to check this test

Estimate with these stats

The simulator makes up thousands of random runs from this test’s win rate and reward-to-risk, then checks each prop firm’s rules. The wins and losses are random, not my trades.

Run the simulator

Open the actual trade log

Every trade from my test, in the order it happened. The numbers on this page come from these trades.

My breakdown

The numbers, from my trade journal export

Every figure in this section is calculated from the trade journal export for this test. The full trade list is in the trade replay on this page.

MarketMES (Micro S&P futures)
Dates2026-01-02 to 2026-04-22
Starting balance$10,000
Trades52
Wins37 (71.2%)
Net+$2,093 (+20.9%)
Profit factor2.40
Worst drawdown$300 (3.0% of start)
Longest losing run3 trades
MonthTradesWinsNet
Jan 20261510+$416
Feb 20261210+$800
Mar 2026149+$399
Apr 2026118+$478

All four months made money, and February won 10 of 12 trades. The account never dropped below its starting balance. Four months of one year is still a short window, so treat the 71% win rate as a ceiling, not an average.

Why I built this

I've tested a lot of opening range breakouts on this channel, and most of them work for a stretch and then stop. So I built my own version with two changes: a longer range, and an entry that waits for a pullback instead of chasing the breakout. I call it about 80% mechanical and 20% judgment.

The rules

Everything is in New York time on the 5-minute MES chart (micro S&P 500 futures).

  1. Mark the range. Instead of the usual 9:30–9:45 or 9:30–10:00 range, I use the high and low of the 9:00–10:00 AM hourly candle.
  2. Wait for a close outside the range. A close above means I'm only looking for buys. A close below means sells.
  3. Find the fair value gap. I don't enter on the breakout candle. I wait for a fair value gap (a three-candle gap left by a fast move). First choice: a gap that lines up with the range high or low, which was the strongest in my testing. Otherwise, a gap formed in the same move that closed outside the range.
  4. Enter with a limit order at the fair value gap.
  5. Stop one tick beyond the first candle of the gap's three candles.
  6. Target 1R, the same distance as the stop.

The judgment is in step 3: picking which gap counts. If the breakout leg leaves no gap, there's no trade. I also made a free TradingView indicator that draws the range and marks the gaps, linked from the video.

How I tested it

I replayed every trading day from January 2 to April 22, 2026 in FX Replay, risking about $100 a trade on a $10,000 account (1%). The first 36 trades were the prop firm test, using FTMO's higher rules: two steps, a 15% profit target, and a 10% maximum drawdown.

What happened

The challenge test (36 trades, to March 18):

  • 26 wins, 10 losses, a 72% win rate
  • +15%, so it passed
  • $2.52 made for every $1 lost, the best I'd had on the channel at the time
  • biggest drop 3% (about $300)

All of 2026 (52 trades):

  • 37 wins, 15 losses, a 71% win rate
  • just under +21%
  • $2.40 made for every $1 lost

At 1R you need more than 50% to make money, so a 71% win rate is a big edge, if it holds. Tuesday was the weak day in both samples, at a 40–43% win rate.

Would a bigger target be better?

FX Replay's risk-reward simulator re-ran the same trades at other targets. On the challenge test, 1.5R looked best: a 64% win rate, $2,100 profit and $2.65 per $1 lost. Over all of 2026, 1.5R gave a 60% win rate and $2,500. I still trade it at 1R, because a high win rate is easier to stick with.

Be honest about the limits

This is my own setup, tested by me, over about four and a half months. That's a short window, and the judgment in step 3 means my results won't exactly match yours. I followed it up with an 82-trade volume profile version and a real challenge. Read those before you trade it, and compare it with the ORB versions I've tested.

The test

How I tested
Manual replay
When
Jan 2 to Apr 22, 2026, from the trade log. The challenge test is the first 36 trades, to Mar 18
Market
MES
Trades
52 trades in the full replay; the first 36 are the challenge test
Risk per trade
About $100 a trade on a $10,000 account (1%), from the trade log
Fees
Not said in the video

The numbers

Risk vs reward1R
Biggest drop3% (~$300)

Every trade, charted

52 trades on MES, from the trade journal export for this test.

$0$1,108$2,215Trade 1Trade 52
Running profit Drop from the last high
Win rate
71.2%
Profit factor
2.40
Net
$2,093 · 20.9R
Biggest drop
-$300 · 3.0R
Longest losing run
3 trades

Would these exact trades pass a 50K challenge?

Same trades, same order, same days. Each trade is resized so a 1R loss costs the amount you pick. Rules from each firm’s help pages (check dates are on the prop firms page); evaluation only, payouts not included.

Risk per trade
FirmStarting on day 1Starting on each day in the log
LucidDailyPassed on trading day 3619 of 52 start days passed · 0 failed
LucidFlexPassed on trading day 3619 of 52 start days passed · 0 failed
Tradeify Select to Flex / Select to DailyPassed on trading day 3619 of 52 start days passed · 0 failed
My Funded Futures RapidPassed on trading day 3619 of 52 start days passed · 0 failed
My Funded Futures Rapid EODPassed on trading day 3619 of 52 start days passed · 0 failed
Apex Trader Funding EODPassed on trading day 3619 of 52 start days passed · 0 failed
Topstep Standard XFA / Consistency XFAPassed on trading day 3619 of 52 start days passed · 0 failed
Take Profit Trader Test to PROPassed on trading day 3619 of 52 start days passed · 0 failed

“Not finished” means the log ended before the target or the drawdown was hit. A short log leaves many late start dates unfinished. Run thousands of random orderings in the simulator →

Trade log

Full 2026 replay, including trades after the challenge target

Download PDFDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.

More from the test

Instrument
MES
Timeframe
5-minute, New York time
Rules
FTMO higher rules: two steps, 15% profit target, 10% max drawdown
Survival test trades
36
Survival test wins
26
Survival test losses
10
Survival test win rate
72%
Survival test profit factor
2.52
Survival test net
+15%
Full 2026 trades
52
Full 2026 win rate
71%
Full 2026 profit factor
2.4
Full 2026 net
just under +21%
Full 2026 wins losses
37 wins / 15 losses
Best RR in simulator
1.5R (64% WR, $2,100, PF 2.65)
Worst day
Tuesday, 40-43% win rate

A note

This is my own setup. Some choices are fixed rules. Some are judgment calls.

Where the numbers come from

Checked Sep 22, 2026. These numbers come from the video and the trade journal export charted above. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.

Original video ↗

Test your own trades

EdgeFinder

The app I built to log a backtest and run it through prop firm challenge rules. It is free to try.

Try EdgeFinder free ↗

Backtest Lab

Members get the code behind my backtests, the results before the video goes public, and a vote on what I test next.

Join Backtest Lab ↗

EdgeFinder is my app and Backtest Lab is my channel membership, so both of these pay me. They never change a test result.