Choosing a Challenge for the Volume Profile Setup
A walkthrough of how to pick a challenge for this setup. Buying a challenge is not the same as passing one.
▶ Watch the videoThe guide, written out
What this page is
Before I put real money behind my volume profile breakout, I had to choose a challenge. This is how I compared firms and why I picked the one I did. Buying a challenge isn't the same as passing one, so this isn't a test result. The strategy's backtest is on the 82-trade replay page.
The prices and ratings below are what I saw when I made the video in June 2026. They change often.
What I check, in order
- The discount. I check each firm's own site for the current price and any active code.
- The reviews. Price means nothing if a firm is slow to pay.
- The rules. These decide whether the challenge actually fits the strategy.
The three firms I compared (25K accounts)
Apex Trader Funding
- Very cheap at the time, $19.90 with a 90% discount
- 3.8 stars from 107 reviews, including one saying they were owed over $20,000 in payouts
- An activation fee after you pass, which I don't like
- Intraday trailing drawdown
- A 30-day time limit
- Needs five winning days of $100 for payouts
The time limit alone was a deal breaker for a strategy that takes one trade a day at most.
My Funded Futures
- 4.5 stars from 236 reviews, with praise for fast payouts and support
- $57 with 50% off, but monthly, and I prefer paying once
- A 50% consistency rule, which is fine for my strategy because every trade uses the same fixed stop and target
- TradingView supported
Lucid Trading
- Good price
- End-of-day drawdown, which is much friendlier to a strategy that holds trades through small pullbacks
- Good payout frequency, and payouts by direct deposit
- TradingView supported
- Bans micro-scalping, hedging and high-frequency trading, and has an inactivity rule, none of which affect this strategy
My pick: Lucid Trading. It was close with My Funded Futures, but the price, the end-of-day drawdown and the payout frequency tipped it.
Why the rules matter more than the price
A fixed 7.5-point stop and 10-point target makes this strategy easy to fit to almost any consistency rule, because no single day is wildly bigger than the others. What it can't handle is an intraday trailing drawdown that tightens on every unrealized high, or a time limit that forces you to trade when there's no setup. Those are the rules to check against how your strategy trades.
The strategy recap
I trade from 10:00 AM and cancel any unfilled order at 2:00 PM. The setup: a fixed range volume profile on 9:00–9:59, 4-point breakout zones beyond the value area, price back inside the value area first, a touch of a zone, then a limit order one tick beyond the fair value gap in the breakout move, with a 7.5-point stop and 10-point target. The rules page has every step.
Takeaway
Pick the challenge to fit the strategy, not the other way round. My 4 prop firm rules to check and the drawdown rules guide go deeper on each rule.
The test
- How I tested
- Guide / walkthrough
- What this is
- This video is not a new backtest.
Trade log
Earlier extended volume-profile backtest; not the live trade in this video
Download PDFDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.A note
I keep this separate from the test results.
Where the numbers come from
Checked Sep 22, 2026. These numbers come from the video. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.
Original video ↗