← All results
Positive test

Eddy’s Volume Profile Breakout — extended replay

The longer replay showed $8,400 profit, a 60% win rate, and a 2.1% drop.

Source Eddy PipsVideo published May 28, 2026
Watch the video
Scorecard · Extended replayMedium sample · 82 trades
Trades
82
Win rate
60%
Profit factor
1.96
Reward : risk
—
Biggest drop
$1,050 (2.1%)
Net result
$8,400

A dash means the video did not report that number.

Two ways to check this test

Estimate with these stats

The simulator makes up thousands of random runs from this test’s win rate and reward-to-risk, then checks each prop firm’s rules. The wins and losses are random, not my trades.

Run the simulator

Open the actual trade log

Every trade from my test, in the order it happened. The numbers on this page come from these trades.

My breakdown

What this test is

This is the longer replay of my volume profile New York breakout, the strategy explained step by step in the rules and live trade page. Before this, it had passed an FXify futures challenge: +6% in 16 trades with a 75% win rate, and it met the consistency rule easily. That challenge file is linked on its own.

The rules, briefly

On the 1-minute MES chart, New York time:

  1. At 10:00 AM, put a fixed range volume profile on 9:00–9:59 to find the value area.
  2. Draw 4-point breakout zones above the value area high and below the value area low.
  3. Once price is inside the value area, wait for it to touch a breakout zone.
  4. Enter at the fair value gap in the move that broke out, one tick beyond it.
  5. 7.5-point stop, 10-point target, about 1.33R.

How I tested it

I replayed every day from January 2 to May 22 (the last date FX Replay had available), risking 7 MES contracts, about 0.5% of the account.

What happened

  • 82 trades over 141 trading days
  • a 60% win rate
  • $1.96 made for every $1 lost
  • $8,400 profit, just over +16% (about +33.6% at 1% risk)
  • biggest drop $1,050 (2.1%)
  • longest winning streak 5, longest losing streak 4

At about 1.33R you break even around 43%, so 60% is a comfortable margin.

By month: January +7.2%, February +1.6%, March +1.9%, April +4.1%, May (to the 22nd) +1.1%. No losing month.

By direction: buys won 67%, sells 50%. That's a meaningful gap, though 82 trades isn't enough to drop sells.

By day: Tuesday made the least, at a 54% win rate over 13 trades, but no day lost money.

How I picked the fair value gap

When there's more than one gap, I use the one created after the shift that broke out, and the one closest to the value area edge. A gap that formed before the breakout move doesn't count. This is the main judgment call in the strategy.

What still needs checking

In the video I pointed out one trade that may have been logged wrong, and FX Replay's risk-reward tool showed slightly different profit numbers from the main result. I've kept the main result separate from that tool. The trade log is downloadable if you want to check it.

Takeaway

This is the most consistent result I've had with my own strategy: no losing month, a 4-loss worst streak and a 2% drop. It's still my own setup tested by me, so the honest next step was trading it with real money, which is what the challenge page covers.

The test

How I tested
Manual replay
When
January 2–May 22, that's what the video says
Market
MES
Trades
82
Risk per trade
7 MES contracts, approximately 0.5%
Fees
Not said in the video

The numbers

Trades82
Win rate60% rounded
Profit vs losses1.96
Profit$8,400, just over 16% reported
Biggest drop$1,050 (2.1%)

Trade log

Extended volume-profile replay (January 2–May 22 as narrated)

Download PDF · 6-month trade logDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.

16-trade challenge replay

Download PDF · Prop firm challengeDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.

More from the test

Instrument
MES
Risk per trade
7 MES contracts, approximately 0.5%
Test window
January 2–May 22, that's what the video says

A note

A separate 16-trade challenge file is linked on its own.

Where the numbers come from

Checked Sep 22, 2026. These numbers come from the video. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.

Original video ↗

Test your own trades

EdgeFinder

The app I built to log a backtest and run it through prop firm challenge rules. It is free to try.

Try EdgeFinder free ↗

Backtest Lab

Members get the code behind my backtests, the results before the video goes public, and a vote on what I test next.

Join Backtest Lab ↗

EdgeFinder is my app and Backtest Lab is my channel membership, so both of these pay me. They never change a test result.

Related videos