Most traders judge a strategy by its win rate. But a win rate means nothing on its own. A 35% win rate can make money, and a 60% win rate can lose it. What decides it is how your win rate compares to your break-even win rate.
What break-even win rate means
Your break-even win rate is the win rate where you neither make nor lose money. It depends only on how big your wins are compared to your losses (your reward-to-risk):
Break-even win rate = 1 ÷ (1 + reward-to-risk)
- At 1:1 (win $100, lose $100), you break even at 50%.
- At 1:1.5, you break even at 40%.
- At 1:2, you break even at about 33%.
- At 1:3, you break even at 25%.
So a strategy that wins 43% of the time at 1:2 is well above its break-even line, and a strategy that wins 52% at 1:1 is only just above it. Fees and slippage push the real break-even point a little higher, so leave yourself some room.
How small an edge is enough at a prop firm?
To answer this, I simulated buying 100 LucidFlex 50K evaluations ($10,500 in fees) and counted what came back after passing, getting funded and taking payouts. Each line below is 100,000 simulated runs, risking $250 a trade:
| Win rate | Reward-to-risk | Above break-even by | Net per 100 evaluations |
|---|---|---|---|
| 48% | 1:1 | −2 points | −$6,418 |
| 50% | 1:1 | 0 | +$1,885 |
| 52% | 1:1 | +2 points | +$21,760 |
| 55% | 1:1 | +5 points | +$89,877 |
| 40% | 1:1.5 | 0 | +$2,146 |
| 42% | 1:1.5 | +2 points | +$23,850 |
| 45% | 1:1.5 | +5 points | +$102,448 |
Two points above break-even was enough to turn a loss into roughly +$20,000 per 100 evaluations. And at 52% and 1:1, about 66 of every 100 evaluations still failed. You'd fail most of your challenges and still come out ahead, because the funded accounts that pay out cover the ones that don't.
That's the main idea of my video Prop Firm Math: You Don't Need a High Win Rate to Get Paid. You don't need a 70% win rate. You need a real edge above your break-even line, and enough attempts for it to show.
Risk size decides how much of the edge you keep
The same 52% at 1:1 strategy gives very different results depending on how much you risk per trade:
- $250 a trade: +$21,760 per 100 evaluations.
- $500 a trade: +$18,509.
- $1,000 a trade: +$7,943.
Bigger risk passes challenges faster, but it also blows funded accounts faster, so fewer of them reach a payout. With a $2,000 drawdown, risking $1,000 a trade means two losses in a row end the account. Smaller risk is slower, but it keeps more accounts alive long enough to get paid.
I saw the same thing in a real strategy test. The Justin Chuk ORB wins about 55.6% at 1:1, which is above break-even. At his own size, risking up to $1,100 a trade, only about 27.7% of challenges passed. Risking a third of the room left in the account, about 51% passed, though it took 9 to 10 months.
How to use this for your own strategy
- Work out your reward-to-risk from your actual trades, not your planned target. If you often move your stop or take profit early, your real ratio is different.
- Find your break-even win rate with the formula above.
- Check your win rate over a big enough sample. Twenty trades can easily be 10 points off your true win rate. A hundred trades is a much better start.
- Run your numbers through the [pass simulator](/simulator) to see how often they pass, and through the 12-month calculator to see what a year of challenges costs and pays.
The catch
All of this assumes your win rate is real. The most common thing I find when I test YouTube strategies is a win-rate claim that doesn't hold up. Nico Trades' ORB reversal was pitched at 80–85% and won 42% in my replay. If your true win rate is below break-even, the prop firm math works against you just as fast as it works for you.