Top 3 Prop-Firm-Proven Strategies (recap)
A recap of three strategies that passed earlier tests, ranked by return versus how far the account fell.
▶ Watch the videoThe guide, written out
What this page is
Most YouTube strategies look good until you put them under prop firm rules. This recap ranks the three that held up best in my tests, by how much they made compared with how far the account fell. It's not a new test. Every number comes from an earlier result page, linked below, where you can see the full trade log.
#3: Liam Merrilees' ICT liquidity sweep model
- Market: MES futures, 15-minute chart, with the 50, 100 and 200 EMAs for direction
- Result: passed both challenge phases in 41 trades
- 46% win rate, biggest drop 8%
- Best target: the original 2R
The catch: it spent its first few months in a drawdown and took 8.5 months to pass both phases. If you're impatient, you'd probably have quit before it recovered.
#2: RamtinFX's daily-candle Fibonacci gold strategy
- Market: gold, risking 0.5% a trade
- Result: a 41% win rate over 100 trades, +21%, biggest drop 7%
- Best target: 2R, which raised the win rate without hurting the total much
The catch: in March it lost 14 trades in a row. It recovered and finished strong, but that streak would test anyone.
#1: The Simplified Trader's SMC session sweep model
- Market: MNQ, a scalping setup built on session sweeps and inverse fair value gaps
- Result: 100 trades, a 43% win rate, finished up
- Best target: the original 2.5R, with 2R close behind at a better win rate
Why it's #1: the best balance of return and drawdown, and its longest losing streak was only four. It didn't need a lucky run to survive.
A correction: in the video I quoted +50% and a 4% drop for this strategy. Those two numbers came from different risk sizes. The trade log PDF shows +18.75% and a 7.98% drop. The 100-trade page has both.
What the three have in common
- Win rates in the low-to-mid 40s. None of them needed a 70% win rate. They all used targets of 2R or more, which puts break-even around 29–33%.
- Clear, mostly mechanical rules. Fewer judgment calls means results you can repeat.
- A rough patch. Each one had a stretch that would have made most people quit. That's normal, and it's why sizing for the worst streak matters more than the win rate. My break-even win rate guide explains why.
Takeaway
If you're choosing a strategy for a prop firm, start with one that has passed over a decent sample, read its worst stretch, and size so you'd survive it twice. You can compare every strategy I've tested on the results page.
The test
- How I tested
- Guide / walkthrough
- What this is
- This video is not a new backtest.
Trade log
Liam Merrilees ICT
Download PDF · Liam Merrilees ICTDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.RamtinFX prop firm
Download PDF · RamtinFX prop firmDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.RamtinFX 100-trade
Download PDF · RamtinFX 100-tradeDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.Simplified Trader prop firm
Download PDF · Simplified Trader prop firmDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.Simplified Trader 100-trade
Download PDF · Simplified Trader 100-tradeDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.What’s in the video
- Rank 3
- Liam Merrilees ICT on MES 15m with 3 EMAs: passed both phases in 41 trades, 46% WR, 8% max drawdown, best RR 2R
- Rank 2
- RamtinFX gold at 0.5% risk: 41% WR, +21%, 7% max drawdown, best RR 2R, 14 losses in a row in March
- Rank 1
- SMC 100-trade recap: 43% win rate
Where the numbers come from
Checked Sep 22, 2026. These numbers come from the video. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.
Original video ↗