← All results
Failed test

Casper SMC One Candle Strategy

It won 1 of 14 trades and hit a 10% drop. Some entry and exit rules were not fully spelled out.

Source Casper SMCVideo published Sep 15, 2025
Watch the video
Scorecard · Challenge replaySmall sample · 14 trades
Trades
14
Win rate
7%
Profit factor
—
Reward : risk
—
Biggest drop
10%
Net result
-10%

A dash means the video did not report that number.

Two ways to check this test

Open the actual trade log

Every trade from my test, in the order it happened. The numbers on this page come from these trades.

My breakdown

The strategy in plain English

Casper SMC has several "one candle" strategies. This is the one he tests on NQ, built around the first 5 minutes of the New York session.

  1. On the 5-minute chart, wait for the 9:30 AM candle to close. Mark its high and low.
  2. Drop to the 1-minute chart and wait for price to close outside the range with a fair value gap (a three-candle gap left by a fast move).
  3. Wait for price to come back into that fair value gap and an engulfing candle to form: a candle whose body completely covers the body of the one before it.
  4. Enter at market on the engulfing candle.
  5. Stop one tick beyond the candle that was engulfed.
  6. Target 3R.

It's mostly mechanical, but two things weren't spelled out in his video: the latest time you can take a trade, and whether you can re-enter after a loss on the same day. I had to pick, so another trader could get different results.

How I tested it

I replayed NQ in FX Replay, logging and journaling every trade so I could show I followed the rules, and tracked it against a prop firm challenge with a 10% loss limit.

What happened

  • 14 trades
  • 1 win, about a 7% win rate
  • −10%, which hit the loss limit

At 3R you only need to win about 25% of trades to break even. One in fourteen is nowhere close.

Why it might have failed

My best guess is the entry. Waiting for price to come back into the gap and print an engulfing candle often gets you in late, after the move has already used up its energy. With a 3R target, the trade then needs a big follow-through that often doesn't come. A tight stop one tick beyond a single 1-minute candle also gets hit by normal noise.

Is 14 trades a fair test?

It's a small sample, and a 3R strategy can have long losing streaks even when it works. But a challenge doesn't care about fairness. Fourteen trades with one winner ended the account, and that's the same thing that would have happened with real money.

Takeaway

If you like Casper's style, his other strategies did better in my tests. His opening range FVG hit about +10% in 23 trades, and his Short Session Method held up on his own dates in a 5-year coded test. Compare them all on the results page.

The test

How I tested
Manual replay
When
Not said in the video
Market
Not said in the video
Trades
14
Risk per trade
Not said in the video
Fees
Not said in the video

The numbers

Trades14
Wins1
Win rate~7%
Return-10%
Biggest drop10%

Trade log

Casper SMC One Candle Strategy

Open trade logOpens the original shared file. Direct download has not been confirmed.

More from the test

Setup
9:30 5-minute range, 1-minute close outside with FVG, engulfing entry, stop one tick below the engulfed candle, 3R target

A note

The cutoff time and re-entry rules were unclear, so someone else might trade this differently.

Where the numbers come from

Checked Sep 22, 2026. These numbers come from the video. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.

Original video ↗

Test your own trades

EdgeFinder

The app I built to log a backtest and run it through prop firm challenge rules. It is free to try.

Try EdgeFinder free ↗

Backtest Lab

Members get the code behind my backtests, the results before the video goes public, and a vote on what I test next.

Join Backtest Lab ↗

EdgeFinder is my app and Backtest Lab is my channel membership, so both of these pay me. They never change a test result.