New York Reversal — first challenge trade
One live challenge trade. Not a finished backtest, and not a passed challenge.
▶ Watch the videoThe guide, written out
What this page is
This is the first trade I took on a $25K prop firm challenge, filmed live and then broken down. It's one trade, so it isn't a backtest and it isn't a passed challenge. It's here to show how I read a New York reversal in real time.
The context
Price was trading at all-time highs, above the previous day's high, the Asia session high and the London session high. When every level above is already taken, I start looking for a reversal down. There was also news that day (a government shutdown), and I felt the market could go either way, so I wanted a clear signal before shorting.
The levels I mark
- Asia session: 8:00 PM to 2:00 AM New York time
- London session: 2:00 AM to 5:00 AM
- The previous day's high and low
- Rebalance fair value gaps on the 1-hour and 15-minute charts. A rebalance fair value gap is one that price came back into, then broke structure from to make a new high or low. I think it's the strongest kind of fair value gap, and the only one I trade. (I have a separate video on it.)
I start looking for trades at 7:00 AM, and execute on the 5-minute chart.
The setup
- On the 1-hour chart, I marked the 8:00 AM candle's high and low, the same idea as the 9am CRT model I'd just tested.
- Price took out the 8 AM candle's high at all-time highs, closed above it, then quickly closed back inside.
- It left a volume imbalance, then closed below a series of up-close candles. For me that's a change in the state of delivery: a sign the direction has flipped.
- I placed a limit order at the body of those up-close candles.
- Targets: the 15-minute rebalance fair value gap first, then the 1-hour one, about 2–2.5R. I used two take-profits with the same stop, on six contracts.
How it played out
Price moved down in my favour. It stalled around the previous day's high, a level price often reacts to, so I took the profit and got out rather than waiting for the final target.
What one trade can and can't tell you
This shows the process: context first, then levels, then a confirmed shift, then defined targets. It doesn't show the strategy works. That takes a full backtest over many trades. The 9am CRT test, which uses a similar 8 AM candle idea without the extra context, failed in 12 trades. That's why I add the context filters here.
Takeaway
If you trade reversals, write down what context you need before you'll take one (here: every major level above already taken) and test it. For how I turn ideas like this into testable rules, see how I backtest a trading strategy.
The test
- How I tested
- Guide / walkthrough
- What this is
- This video is not a new backtest.
Trade log
No trade log is linked for this guide.
A note
I keep this separate from the test results.
Where the numbers come from
Checked Sep 22, 2026. These numbers come from the video. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.
Original video ↗