← All results
Failed test

Simplified Trader 9am CRT Model

The account hit the 10% loss limit in 12 trades. Ten of those were losses in a row.

Source The Simplified TraderVideo published Sep 24, 2025
Watch the video
Scorecard · Challenge replaySmall sample · 12 trades
Trades
12
Win rate
17%
Profit factor
—
Reward : risk
—
Biggest drop
~10% (limit)
Net result
—

Win rate worked out from 2 wins in 12 trades

A dash means the video did not report that number.

Two ways to check this test

Open the actual trade log

I haven’t published a trade log for this test. The numbers on this page come from the results shown in the video.

My breakdown

The claim

This was one of the most requested tests on the channel. The Simplified Trader says his simplified 9:00 AM CRT model can earn $1,000 a day. CRT stands for candle range theory: the idea that price often sweeps one end of a big candle's range and then reverses.

The strategy in plain English

He shows it on GBPUSD, so that's what I tested. Times are New York.

  1. On the 1-hour chart, wait for the 8:00 AM candle to close and mark its high and low.
  2. You can only enter before 10:00 AM. You can hold the trade after that.
  3. On the 5-minute chart, wait for price to sweep (go beyond) the high or the low.
  4. Wait for a 5-minute candle to close with its body back inside the range.
  5. Drop to the 1-minute chart. Look for another small sweep of a recent high or low, followed by a change in the state of delivery (CISD): price closing back through the start of the last move, a sign the direction has flipped.
  6. Enter on that shift, with the stop beyond the sweep.

Steps 5 and 6 need judgment. Spotting a valid CISD on the 1-minute chart isn't something two traders will always agree on.

What happened

It failed fast:

  • 12 trades
  • 2 wins, 10 losses
  • 10 losses in a row
  • the account hit the 10% loss limit and the challenge was over

I stopped there, because that's when a real challenge would have ended.

Was the target the problem?

FX Replay's risk-reward simulator re-ran the same 12 trades at different targets. At 1R, the win rate would have been 58%, but the profit only about $200. So a smaller target turns the losers into small winners, but it doesn't turn the strategy into a $1,000-a-day system.

Is 12 trades enough to judge it?

Not to judge the idea forever. Twelve trades is a tiny sample, and 10 losses in a row can happen to a decent strategy. But it's enough to judge the claim. A strategy that makes $1,000 a day shouldn't open with 10 straight losses, and in a real challenge, those 12 trades would have cost you the account.

Takeaway

CRT strategies are popular because the idea is easy to see on a chart after the fact. Turning it into rules that work going forward is much harder. If you want to see a CRT test with a much bigger sample, I coded Nitro Trades' CRT and ran it over 10 years. It didn't make clear money either. My guide on whether YouTube strategies work explains why claims like "$1,000 a day" rarely hold up.

The test

How I tested
Manual replay
When
Not said in the video
Market
Not said in the video
Trades
12
Risk per trade
Not said in the video
Fees
Not said in the video

The numbers

Trades12
Wins2
Losses10
Biggest drop~10% (challenge limit)

Trade log

I have not published a trade log for this test. The numbers on this page come from the results shown in the video.

More from the test

Creator claim
$1,000 a day
Max consecutive losses
10
RR simulation
1R would have given 58% WR but only $200 profit

A note

I stopped when the challenge would have failed. Twelve trades is a small sample.

Where the numbers come from

Checked Sep 22, 2026. These numbers come from the video. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.

Original video ↗

Test your own trades

EdgeFinder

The app I built to log a backtest and run it through prop firm challenge rules. It is free to try.

Try EdgeFinder free ↗

Backtest Lab

Members get the code behind my backtests, the results before the video goes public, and a vote on what I test next.

Join Backtest Lab ↗

EdgeFinder is my app and Backtest Lab is my channel membership, so both of these pay me. They never change a test result.