Trading Rush MACD — original and London-only tests
The first test made money but did not hit the challenge goal. A London-only follow-up looked better.
▶ Watch the video- Trades
- 68
- Win rate
- 43%
- Profit factor
- —
- Reward : risk
- 1.5R
- Biggest drop
- —
- Net result
- ~+6–7%
Video reports 68–69 trades and a 43–44% win rate; lower figure shown
A dash means the video did not report that number.
Two ways to check this test
My breakdown
The strategy
Five years ago, Trading Rush backtested his MACD strategy 100 times and reported a 62% win rate and about 50% profit. The video got 1.4 million views. I wanted to know if it could still pass a prop firm challenge in 2025.
The rules in plain English
Chart setup: a 30-minute chart with a 200 EMA, and the MACD indicator on its default settings. Add a horizontal line at zero on the MACD so the crosses are easy to see.
Buy when:
- Price is above the 200 EMA (the trend is up).
- The MACD and signal lines are both below zero.
- The MACD line crosses up through the signal line. You'll see the histogram flip from red to green.
Sell when: the mirror image. Price below the 200 EMA, both lines above zero, and a cross down.
Entry, stop and target: enter at market, put the stop beyond the recent swing, and target 1.5R.
How I tested it
I replayed EURJPY from January to October 2025 in FX Replay and tracked it against prop firm rules.
What happened
The original rules:
- about 68–69 trades
- a 43–44% win rate
- about +6–7%
At 1.5R you break even around 40%, so 43–44% made a small profit, but not enough to reach a typical challenge target in ten months.
London only: when I split the trades by session, the London session stood out, so I ran a follow-up taking London trades only:
- about 26–27 trades
- a 65–67% win rate
- about +17–18%
The video moves between 68 and 69 trades, and 26 and 27, depending on which tool is on screen, so I've kept the ranges rather than picking one.
Be careful with the London result
I picked London after seeing which session did best. That's useful as an idea, but it isn't a fresh test, and choosing the best slice of past results almost always makes a strategy look better than it will be. To trust it, you'd need to test London-only on months that weren't part of this test.
Also, EURJPY is a forex pair. A futures prop firm won't let you trade it, so check that your firm offers the market before building a plan around it.
Takeaway
The MACD strategy still has a small edge on EURJPY, but nowhere near the 62% from the original video. The London-only version is the interesting part, and the next step would be testing it on new data. If you're wondering why a 43% win rate can still make money, see break-even win rate.
The test
- How I tested
- Manual replay
- When
- January–October 2025
- Market
- EURJPY
- Trades
- More than one stretch of trades. See below.
- Risk per trade
- Not said in the video
- Fees
- Not said in the video
The numbers
Trade log
MACD backtest
Download PDF · MACD backtestDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.London-only test
Download PDF · London-only testDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.More from the test
- Instrument
- EURJPY
- Test window
- January–October 2025
- Original reported
- 68–69 trades; approximately +6–7%; 43–44% win rate
- London only reported
- 26–27 trades; approximately +17–18%; 65–67% win rate
A note
I picked London only after looking at the sessions, so it is not a fresh test. A EURJPY strategy is not automatically allowed at a futures firm.
Where the numbers come from
Checked Sep 22, 2026. These numbers come from the video. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.
Original video ↗