← All results
Mixed results

Casper SMC 5-minute Break and Retest

At 0.5% risk, 107 trades finished about even. At 1% risk, the challenge failed in 17 trades.

Source Casper SMCVideo published Mar 9, 2026
Watch the video
Scorecard · Replay at 0.5% riskLarge sample · 107 trades
Trades
107
Win rate
—
Profit factor
1.01
Reward : risk
—
Biggest drop
7.5%
Net result
+0.5%

A dash means the video did not report that number.

Two ways to check this test

Open the actual trade log

Every trade from my test, in the order it happened. The numbers on this page come from these trades.

My breakdown

The strategy in plain English

This is another version of Casper SMC's 5-minute opening range idea, and it's completely mechanical:

  1. At 9:35 AM, the first 5-minute candle (9:30–9:35) closes. Mark its high and low.
  2. Wait for a 5-minute candle to close completely outside the range. A wick doesn't count.
  3. Wait for a retest: price comes back to the level, but the retest candle must close outside the range again.
  4. Enter on that retest.
  5. Stop at the midpoint (50%) of the original range.
  6. Target 2R.

How I tested it

I had MES and MNQ open side by side and took whichever triggered first. If both triggered at once, I took MES. I replayed from January 1 to July 1, then added February 2026 as a recent check.

What happened

At 0.5% risk, over 107 trades:

  • about $1.01 made for every $1 lost, which is break-even
  • +0.5% in total
  • biggest drop 7.5%
  • 13 losses in a row

At 1% risk, the challenge failed in 17 trades.

February 2026 on its own was clearly positive. But that's the trap: one good month can convince you a strategy works, and then choppy markets and losing streaks give it all back.

What's going wrong

My best read is the combination of two things:

  • Breakouts and retests at a volatile open. The market often pulls back hard after the first break, right through the retest.
  • A stop at the midpoint of the range. When the 9:30 candle is small, the midpoint is close, and normal noise hits it.

Together, setups look valid and then get stopped out over and over.

What about a smaller target? On the same trades, FX Replay's simulator showed 1R would have made money, at about $1.28 per $1 lost and roughly a 56% win rate. Better, but still not a strong edge, and it's a what-if on the same trades.

Takeaway

As it stands, this version isn't reliable enough to pass a prop firm challenge, and a 13-loss streak at 1% risk would end most accounts. If you want a Casper opening range strategy, his opening range FVG version did better in my test, though on a much smaller sample. And for why a good month isn't proof, see whether YouTube strategies work.

The test

How I tested
Manual replay
When
January–July plus February 2026 check; first window’s year not explicit
Market
MES / MNQ; first signal, MES on ties
Trades
107
Risk per trade
Not said in the video
Fees
Not said in the video

The numbers

Trades107
Profit vs losses1.01
Return+0.5% at 0.5% risk
Biggest drop7.5% at 0.5% risk

Trade log

Casper SMC 5-minute Break and Retest

Download PDFDownload endpoint checked 2026-09-22. Contents may differ from the video; see source notes.

More from the test

Instrument
MES / MNQ; first signal, MES on ties
Max consecutive losses
13
Test window
January–July plus February 2026 check; first window’s year not explicit

A note

A recent-month check and a different exit on the same trades do not prove the setup works.

Where the numbers come from

Checked Sep 22, 2026. These numbers come from the video. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.

Original video ↗

Test your own trades

EdgeFinder

The app I built to log a backtest and run it through prop firm challenge rules. It is free to try.

Try EdgeFinder free ↗

Backtest Lab

Members get the code behind my backtests, the results before the video goes public, and a vote on what I test next.

Join Backtest Lab ↗

EdgeFinder is my app and Backtest Lab is my channel membership, so both of these pay me. They never change a test result.