← All results
Mixed results

Faiz SMC 8am Candle

It passed the first step, then did not finish the second. The biggest drop was $2,533 (10%).

Source Faiz SMCVideo published Sep 4, 2025
Watch the video
Scorecard · Two-phase challenge replaySample size not stated
Trades
—
Win rate
44%
Profit factor
—
Reward : risk
—
Biggest drop
10% ($2,533)
Net result
—

A dash means the video did not report that number.

Two ways to check this test

Open the actual trade log

Every trade from my test, in the order it happened. The numbers on this page come from these trades.

EdgeFinder is my app, so it pays me. It never changes a test result. No account needed to open the trades.

My breakdown

The numbers, from my trade journal export

Every figure in this section is calculated from the trade journal export for this test. The full trade list is in the trade replay on this page.

MarketMNQ (Micro Nasdaq futures)
Dates2025-01-02 to 2025-08-21
Starting balance$25,000
Trades114
Wins48 (42.1%)
Net+$2,656 (+10.6%)
Profit factor1.33
Worst drawdown$2,533 (10.1% of start)
Longest losing run10 trades
MonthTradesWinsNet
Jan 2025189+$581
Feb 2025178+$444
Mar 2025126+$766
Apr 2025165–$260
May 2025132–$1,152
Jun 2025157+$1,109
Jul 202583+$137
Aug 2025158+$1,032

The first three months were steady. April and May lost $1,412 between them (May won only 2 of 13), and that is where phase 2 stalled. June and August recovered most of it.

The strategy in plain English

Faiz SMC says "this one candle can change your life". The candle is the 8:00 AM hourly candle, New York time.

  1. At 9:00 AM, wait for the 8:00 AM hourly candle to close. Mark its high and low. These are the levels where stop orders are likely sitting.
  2. Drop to the 1-minute chart and draw a line at 9:30 AM. You can only trade after 9:30.
  3. Wait for price to sweep (go beyond) the high or the low after 9:30.
  4. Wait for a market structure shift: price breaks the most recent swing point in the other direction and closes back inside the 8 AM range.
  5. Enter on a pullback to any "PD array": a fair value gap, an order block or a breaker block.
  6. Stop beyond the sweep. Target 2R.

Step 5 is where judgment comes in. There's usually more than one valid entry zone, and they give different results. In the video I usually picked the zone where several lined up.

I also managed winners: partial profit at 2R and the stop moved to break-even. That brought the average win to about 1.6R.

How I tested it

I replayed from January to August and tracked it against FTMO's two-phase rules.

What happened

  • Phase 1 passed, in about three months.
  • Phase 2 didn't finish. It neither passed nor failed by August.
  • 44% win rate, as reported in the video. The trade log counts each partial close as its own row, 114 in all, which works out to 42%.
  • biggest drop $2,533 (10%) from the trade log, right at FTMO's 10% limit

Month by month: just under +2% in January, +3% in March, then −1% in April and −4% in May. The spring months gave back much of what the first quarter made.

What this shows

At an average win of about 1.6R, the break-even win rate is about 38%. A 42–44% win rate is above that, but not by much, and a 10% drop against a 10% limit leaves no room at all. It's a strategy with a small edge and a lot of judgment, which is a hard combination: your results depend heavily on which entry zone you pick.

Takeaway

If you like Faiz's approach, the most useful thing you can do is pin down step 5. Pick one entry type (for example, only fair value gaps) and test that alone. My SMC inverse FVG test is an example of a similar idea with fixed rules that held up over 100 trades.

The test

How I tested
Manual replay
When
January to August
Market
Not said in the video
Trades
More than one stretch of trades. See below.
Risk per trade
Not said in the video
Fees
Not said in the video

The numbers

Win rate44%
Biggest drop$2,533 (10%)

Every trade, charted

114 trades on MNQ, from the trade journal export for this test.

-$500$1,140$2,781Trade 1Trade 114
Running profit Drop from the last high
Win rate
42.1%
Profit factor
1.33
Net
$2,656 · 17.5R
Biggest drop
-$2,533 · 19.2R
Longest losing run
10 trades

Would these exact trades pass a 50K challenge?

Same trades, same order, same days. Each trade is resized so a 1R loss costs the amount you pick. Rules from each firm’s help pages (check dates are on the prop firms page); evaluation only, payouts not included.

Risk per trade
FirmStarting on day 1Starting on each day in the log
LucidDailyPassed on trading day 2817 of 62 start days passed · 20 failed
LucidFlexPassed on trading day 2817 of 62 start days passed · 20 failed
Tradeify Select to Flex / Select to DailyPassed on trading day 2817 of 62 start days passed · 20 failed
My Funded Futures RapidPassed on trading day 2817 of 62 start days passed · 20 failed
My Funded Futures Rapid EODPassed on trading day 2816 of 62 start days passed · 20 failed
Apex Trader Funding EODPassed on trading day 2817 of 62 start days passed · 20 failed
Topstep Standard XFA / Consistency XFAPassed on trading day 2817 of 62 start days passed · 20 failed
Take Profit Trader Test to PROPassed on trading day 2817 of 62 start days passed · 20 failed

“Not finished” means the log ended before the target or the drawdown was hit. A short log leaves many late start dates unfinished. Run thousands of random orderings in the simulator →

Trade log

All 114 positions from the replay, January to August 2025

Open trade log in EdgeFinderOpens every trade in EdgeFinder, the app I built. No account needed.

More from the test

Rules
FTMO two-phase
Outcome
Passed phase 1 (~3 months), did not finish phase 2
Average RR
~1.6 after partials at 2R and stop to break-even
Test window
January to August
Monthly
Just under +2% Jan, +3% Mar, -1% Apr, -4% May

A note

When the video compares other firms, that is not a full replay of each firm’s rules. The video reports a 44% win rate. The trade log lists each partial close as its own row, 114 in all, and works out to 42%.

Where the numbers come from

Checked Sep 22, 2026. These numbers come from the video and the trade journal export charted above. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.

Original video ↗

Open these trades yourself

EdgeFinder

The trades from this test are loaded in EdgeFinder, the app I built. Open them to see every stat and how they hold up against each prop firm's rules. No account needed.

Open these trades in EdgeFinder ↗

Backtest Lab

Members get the code behind my backtests, the results before the video goes public, and a vote on what I test next.

Join Backtest Lab ↗

EdgeFinder is my app and Backtest Lab is my channel membership, so both of these pay me. They never change a test result.