15-Minute ORB (107-trade extension)
The longer 107-trade test finished up 2.16%, but the biggest drop was $1,345 (13%). It was not a new challenge pass.
▶ Watch the video- Trades
- 107
- Win rate
- —
- Profit factor
- —
- Reward : risk
- —
- Biggest drop
- 13% ($1,345)
- Net result
- +2.16%
A dash means the video did not report that number.
Two ways to check this test
EdgeFinder is my app, so it pays me. It never changes a test result. No account needed to open the trades.
My breakdown
The numbers, from my trade journal export
Every figure in this section is calculated from the trade journal export for this test. The full trade list is in the trade replay on this page.
| Market | MNQ (Micro Nasdaq futures) |
| Dates | 2025-05-02 to 2025-09-30 |
| Starting balance | $10,000 |
| Trades | 107 |
| Wins | 38 (35.5%) |
| Net | +$216 (+2.2%) |
| Profit factor | 1.03 |
| Worst drawdown | $1,345 (13.5% of start) |
| Longest losing run | 6 trades |
| Month | Trades | Wins | Net |
|---|---|---|---|
| May 2025 | 20 | 8 | +$257 |
| Jun 2025 | 20 | 8 | +$403 |
| Jul 2025 | 24 | 10 | +$533 |
| Aug 2025 | 20 | 5 | –$744 |
| Sep 2025 | 23 | 7 | –$232 |
May to July made $1,193. Then August won only 5 of 20 trades and lost $744, and September lost another $232. The pass headline came from a good stretch. This extension shows what came after it.
Why I ran it again
Three weeks before this video, the 15-minute ORB passed a prop firm challenge. Over 73 trades from January to April 2025, it made 21% with about a 48% win rate. That's a good result, but four months is a short window. So I kept going with the same rules for the rest of the year.
The rules
- On the 15-minute chart, mark the high and low of the 9:30 AM candle.
- On the 5-minute chart, wait for a candle to close outside that range.
- Enter at market right away.
- Stop 5 points beyond the middle (50%) of the 15-minute range.
- Target 2R, and close at 4:00 PM if neither is hit.
What happened
From May to the end of September 2025, 107 trades:
- 38 winners, 69 losers, about a 35% win rate
- only +2.16%
- biggest drop $1,345 (13% of the starting balance) from the trade log
The video's numbers don't line up perfectly (38 + 69 is 107, but 35% of 107 isn't exactly 38), so I've left the win rate as reported rather than recomputing it.
The equity curve tells the story better than the totals. It started choppy, spent a long stretch below the starting balance, had one winning run, and then gave most of it back. It never stayed above the starting balance for long. Two more trades I took in October were also losses.
Same strategy, two different results
| January–April | May–September | |
|---|---|---|
| Trades | 73 | 107 |
| Win rate | ~48% | ~35% |
| Result | +21%, passed | +2.16% |
Nothing about the rules changed. The market did. An ORB depends on clean moves away from the open, and when the market chops back and forth after 9:30, breakouts fail and the tight stop at the middle of the range gets hit more often.
A note on targets
In the first test, FX Replay's risk-reward simulator showed that 1.5R would have given a 55% win rate and more profit than 2R. That's worth knowing, but it came from the good stretch, so it may not help in a choppy one.
Takeaway
"It passed a challenge" and "it works" are not the same thing. If I'd stopped after the first video, this would look like a winning strategy. With five more months, it looks like break-even with a 13% drop. Before you trade any ORB, test it across several kinds of markets. My ORB results guide puts this next to the versions that held up better.
The test
- How I tested
- Manual replay
- When
- May–September 2025
- Market
- Not said in the video
- Trades
- 107
- Risk per trade
- Not reconciled; 13% drawdown in the trade log
- Fees
- Not said in the video
The numbers
Every trade, charted
107 trades on MNQ, from the trade journal export for this test.
- Win rate
- 35.5%
- Profit factor
- 1.03
- Net
- $216 · 2.2R
- Biggest drop
- -$1,345 · 13.4R
- Longest losing run
- 6 trades
Would these exact trades pass a 50K challenge?
Same trades, same order, same days. Each trade is resized so a 1R loss costs the amount you pick. Rules from each firm’s help pages (check dates are on the prop firms page); evaluation only, payouts not included.
| Firm | Starting on day 1 | Starting on each day in the log |
|---|---|---|
| LucidDaily | Failed on trading day 85 | 0 of 104 start days passed · 73 failed |
| LucidFlex | Failed on trading day 85 | 0 of 104 start days passed · 73 failed |
| Tradeify Select to Flex / Select to Daily | Failed on trading day 84 | 0 of 104 start days passed · 74 failed |
| My Funded Futures Rapid | Failed on trading day 85 | 0 of 104 start days passed · 73 failed |
| My Funded Futures Rapid EOD | Failed on trading day 85 | 0 of 104 start days passed · 73 failed |
| Apex Trader Funding EOD | Failed on trading day 84 | 0 of 104 start days passed · 74 failed |
| Topstep Standard XFA / Consistency XFA | Failed on trading day 86 | 0 of 104 start days passed · 70 failed |
| Take Profit Trader Test to PRO | Failed on trading day 86 | 0 of 104 start days passed · 70 failed |
“Not finished” means the log ended before the target or the drawdown was hit. A short log leaves many late start dates unfinished. Run thousands of random orderings in the simulator →
Trade log
All 107 trades from the extension
Open trade log in EdgeFinderOpens every trade in EdgeFinder, the app I built. No account needed.More from the test
- Entry rules
- 9:30 15-minute candle high/low, 5-minute close outside the range, market execute, stop 5 points beyond the 50% of the range
- Prior result
- An earlier video passed a prop firm challenge over the first four months of the year
- Test window
- May–September 2025
A note
Drawdown is from the trade log: $1,345, 13% of the starting balance.
Where the numbers come from
Checked Sep 22, 2026. These numbers come from the video and the trade journal export charted above. They are backtest or simulated results, not live trading, and not financial advice.
Original video ↗